TUKANG
UNITEDSTEEL CONSTRUCTION
Discuss Your Project

Structural Steel Journal · TUKANG UNITED

ASTM A325 Bolted vs Field-Welded Connections: Technical Analysis for Bali Steel Structures

The choice is not determined by assuming bolts are easier or welds are stronger.

Steel construction illustration
Steel construction illustration.

The choice is not determined by assuming bolts are easier or welds are stronger.

1. Select bolting or welding through connection design

The choice is not determined by assuming bolts are easier or welds are stronger. Review the forces, required stiffness, installation access, tolerances, and erection sequence. Simple connections and moment connections require different details. Shop welding with site bolting can be considered where it fits the design.

2. A325 and class 8.8 are different specifications

A325 is now a grade within ASTM F3125. Property class 8.8 belongs to a different ISO classification system. Procurement should identify the approved standard, grade, diameter, length, nuts, washers, and coating condition. The grade alone does not determine whether a joint is snug-tightened, pretensioned, or slip-critical; the designer specifies the joint type.

3. Why there is no universal bolt torque table

Installation torque depends on the bolting assembly and its condition. A fixed torque based only on diameter does not demonstrate correct pretension. Follow the installation and verification procedures of the project-referenced edition. The RCSC standards page notes that the calibrated wrench method was withdrawn in the 2025 edition. Projects referencing another edition must follow their contract documents rather than mix editions.

4. Site welding: procedures, access, and inspection

Where AWS D1.1 is specified, procedure and welder qualifications, joint preparation, inspection, and acceptance follow the project edition. UT, MT, PT, or other examinations are selected for the joint and inspection requirements. Not every weld requires every NDT method, and UT/PT is not the routine verification of bolt pretension.

5. Pre-work discussion checklist

Request connection drawings, bolting assembly specifications or WPS, inspection requirements, and responsibility boundaries. Record revisions before fabrication. Do not substitute bolt grades, weld lengths, holes, or plates simply because materials are available. Retain inspection records and approved changes for handover.

Project questions

Can these details be used directly for any project?

No. Sections, connections, methods, and inspection criteria must follow the project design, specified standard editions, and relevant product data.

Technical references

Technical Journal Exploration

Explore Related Structural Engineering Guides

Deepen your understanding of structural steel standards, precision fabrication methods, and building engineering in Bali.

Browse Journal Directory →

Start Your Project Discussion

Plan your structural steelwork with Bali specialists.

We review your structural drawings, member sizing, and site access constraints before fabrication starts.

WhatsApp Consultation
Calculate Estimate Chat WhatsApp